ChristianBlog.Com Home About Register Login Join For Free

The spiritual dangers in nationalistic patriotism

I have labored over how to present this material for quite some time. There is no easy or non-controversial way to do it. All I can do is lay out "my case" the best I can and pray that in the process I do not offend anyone too badly. Please let it be known that this is NOT a political commentary nor is it intended to pass any judgment on the new President of these United States.

We are squarely in the middle of what, for some, is the greatest celebration in the history of mankind. Much of what is going on in Washington happens to some degree every four years, but this year is unprecedented as far as scope, size and expense. I choose not to be involved in any way due to my particular beliefs. I do not mind that others are so excited about their candidate being sworn in as the new President. It is their privilege and I honestly pray he does as good of job as his supporters believe he will do.

My problem lies in a word which is used by every President, regardless of political affiliation. My issue is not with any person, but their use of a particular word which happens to go against my faith. The word which offends me does just the opposite for most Americans. Therein lays the dilemma I face in trying to present my problems with this word and all it represents without succeeding in offending others.

The word which I have these problems with is the word "patriotism" or "patriotic". Of course both of these words stem from the word "patriot" which simply means to be a supporter of one's country. These words imply that a person is a proud supporter or defender of his or her country and its way of life. Wrapped up in these words are terms such as "nationalistic", "devoted" and "loyal". When this devotion and loyalty is directed towards one's nation it defines patriotism.

Here are my problems in a nutshell. First of all, I have severe issues with what my country represents and its way of life. There are many excellent things about the United States of America, just as there are concerning many other countries. But, there are also extremely horrible things about this country (and all others too) that have developed in the past two or three generations which makes it very difficult to remain "patriotic". The United States of America today is NOT the same country I was grew up in.

In no way am I diminishing the role those who serve in the Armed Forces play in defending this country. Those who give their lives in service are my heroes in many respects. My issue is with what they are defending and whether this country stands for the same things it did years ago. Many who are celebrating this week in Washington say it does. But, simply electing a particular man to be President does not in itself mean the country is suddenly an oasis of freedom and a shrine to the excellence of everyone who lives there.

As you might tell, I am no patriot. I do not hate my country, but neither do I love it. Where and how patriotism has come to by synonymous with being a good Christian bewilders me. I do not see any evidence in the New Testament that we are to be proud and zealous nationalists who will run to war at the drop of a hat to fight for the country of our birth. I have struggled for years with trying to understand how patriotism and Christianity have much of anything to do with each other.

When looking at the word "loyalty" it is very apparent that great caution must be exercised when using this word outside of God. The word "loyal" means; remaining faithful to a country, person, ruler, government, or ideal. When Peter and John were hauled before the Sanhedrin in Acts and threatened with harsh penalties if they continued to preach Jesus Christ; their response was simply "We ought to obey God rather than men."

Who exactly is worthy of our loyalty? Who is big enough, caring enough and in every way worthy enough to demand our faithfulness? Is not God and God alone the only one who we should seek to be loyal to?

When stepping up to the next word, devotion, there is NO doubt this word should be used exclusively toward God. The word devotion means; committed love (deep love and commitment), dedication (great dedication and loyalty) and enthusiasm (strong enthusiasm and admiration for somebody or something). Honestly, who else besides God and His Son Jesus Christ is worthy of our devotion, dedication and loyalty?

When I hear politicians tell us that such and such is our "Patriotic duty", it makes my skin crawl. My only patriotic duty according to the Bible is to pay taxes and obey the laws of the land. When someone starts telling me it is my "patriotic duty" to do anything else, I quickly become "unpatriotic". My loyalty, dedication and devotion belongs to my God not some governmental authority. I am more than willing to pay tribute to whom tribute is due, but I am not willing to sell my soul to the earthly country in which I live.

As I said at the beginning, this is a very difficult subject to formulate without sounding unthankful for the service given by those in the military or those whose profession involves working for the government. Those issues are, to me, entirely different than the subject du jour which for the next couple of days will be "patriotism" and how it is our "duty" as Americans to sacrifice, give, serve, spend and other things.

President Kennedy's most famous line from his inauguration speech was of course; "Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country." I am sure some variation of those words will be spoken many times in various addresses this week. I am sure we will all hear that it is our "patriotic duty" to do and allow to be done all sorts of things "for the good of the country". I am sure millions upon millions of people will be whipped into a patriotic frenzy and proceed to do as they are told. This scares me to no end.

Business is business, politics are politics and the things of God should be the things of God. This is how things should be instead of mixing them together. When there are no longer any lines separating the things of business, the state and religion, bad things are bound to happen. My view, for what it is worth, is that our "patriotism", along with our loyalty, dedication and devotion need to stay directed toward God and the things of God and not intermingled with patriotism to this country or the world and their causes.

posted: 01/20/2009 03:22am by blessings2you
View: Backlinks, Permalink
Total Views: 511
ShortURL: http://christianblog.com/ede9
Category: Religious Freedom
Print This Blog Entry
Blog Tags: countrydevotionloyaltypatrioticpatriotismword
Share: Share Via Email  Share On Twitter.Com  Share On Facebook.Com  Share On Digg.Com  Share On Digg.Com  Post To Evernote  Share On StumbleUpon.Com  Share On Propeller.Com  Share On Technorati.Com  Share On FriendFeed.Com  Share On Reddit.Com 
 

Author Details:

Author: blessings2you
Location: Warrenton Missouri USA
Gender: Male
Age: 57
Blog Entries: 827 (archive)
Blog Comments: 1357

My Biography:

god called me to serve him when i was 16 years old while on a church work trip in new mexico in 1969. in the 40 years since; i attended bible school/leadership training, been ordained to the christian ministry and worked full time for a non-denominational ministry for nearly ten... view full biography

My Testimony:

in 1969 god stepped in and transformed my life as a sixteen year old teenager. after a couple of years of intense emotional ups and downs, i decided i needed a firm foundation in my life that went beyond emotional experiences. it was the decision to become involved with a... view full testimony

My Recent Blogs:

Putting Washington's ...
Entitlement mentality--fr...
A very legitimate questio...
The need for separation o...
What is the REAL news...
I can do ...(with a littl...
The mystery of me...
I STILL have a dream...
Is gambling really just e...
What can we do for our co...

My Family:

My Closest Friends:


VERY good points, my friend. I agree with you about the modern concept of patriotism.

I grew up with a very different view of what the word "patriot" means. My dad was a thoughtful, studious Christian. He searched the scriptures for instruction on everything from how to live his own life, to how to raise his family, to how to view his country. I suppose his view of what a patriot is could be summed up by one line of the pledge of allegiance:

"One nation under God"

Dad believed that this country was great, not because of affluence nor military might, but because of its individuals, families, and communities working together to help each other with Godly principles. Dad's idea of being a patriot was taking care of your neighbors, and defending our country against any who would try to take away our freedom or our beliefs.

You see, like many of us here, I grew up in an era when the big scare was that communism would try to take over the world, us included. Communism was considered by many to be the essence of evil. It was Godless, amoral, and would destroy us if we let it in. So "patriotism" to my dad was, at the time, wrapped up in keeping this country safe from the influx of communism.

After my dad did some more studying on world events, he learned about "socialism." Then his attention turned to the fact that socialism was creeping into our way of live incrementally. He was just as afraid of that happening as he had been about communism. JFK had pretty much eased the minds of many of that day about communist countries taking us over by force. Socialism was a kinder, gentler word. It was all about everyone being equal, and having everything they needed. It was not linked to thoughts of dictatorial style government.

Our enemies have changed. While once we were patriots if we defended our faith and way of life against those who would forcibly remove it from us, we are now patriots if we embrace everyone's beliefs, including those who have abandoned God's will. We are now expected to defend the "rights" of atheists.

I like the idea of being a patriot like my dad. He worked hard, took care of his family to the best of his ability, then spread his concern to the community, and then to our great country as he saw it:

"One nation under God"

That is a patriotism I could live with.

  Posted 01/20/2009 03:50am
Author: philruby

Excellent points Phil, Thank you for adding these things to the discussion here. As you say, much has changed since the era in which we grew up, including the very definition of the word "patriot". Thank you again for your insight and comment.
B2Y

  Posted 01/20/2009 03:58am
Author: blessings2you

Very good blog, B2Y. Very good points, very well written, and very true.
I have to say that I haven't given much though to patriotism beyond the idea of gratitude... I considered myself patriotic because I was grateful for the freedoms I enjoy. Grateful to God that I live in this country, and grateful to the men and women who made it possible. Nothing more, nothing less.
This will give my mind more to munch on.

  Posted 01/20/2009 07:32am
Author: whobelieve

From about the late 70's on, i became aware of a patriot movement in the U.S. that believed that a large part of patriotism was to resist big government and especially the Feds? To them patriotism was to quietly forming their own army for self-defense rather than joining the military that they believed had become part of a larger international military? And so as you say 'patriot' is an explosive subject with multiple conflicting meanings.

In those days i stayed my course of action which was to evangelize, with the idea that the best thing i could do with my life was to win as many people as i could to Christ and that 'one at a time'. Now, i have added to that a careful look at the underground Church in various oppressed countries. There may come a day soon when they will have a lot to teach us about survival.

Now, within a few minutes the new president will be sworn into office and i hope that all is well. The patriot in me cries out, 'we have no King but Jesus' and 'give me Jesus or give me death'.

  Posted 01/20/2009 08:51am
Author: bimonics

Even though you make very valid points I can't help but remember the actions of David before He becomes the King. He refuses to take up his weapon in his own saftey against King Saul because of his respect for the King his Lord placed there. I do honor those moments of respect for those whom are allowed to led us by our Lord. We may not understand the policies and we can all dispute the actions of The Presidents yet we can not doubt that our Lord has put in place those who have authority over us. It is with this respect that I give honor and my duty to them. I understand your position and respect it. I too have many problems with the problems that are brought upon us by politics. In many ways todays leaders are not unlike the one that King David had to continue to hide from. I believe strongly in the values that this country was built upon and ache with pain to see its values stripped in the name of those who choose to worship their own lives and their own accomplishments. I also pray in the name of Jesus that our Lord will conitnue to allow us to be protected by His strong arm.

Blessings,
bubba

  Posted 01/20/2009 10:37am
Author: bubbavela

Great blog, B2Y. I began to comment and wrote a blog instead. Thanks for getting me thinking.

  Posted 01/20/2009 11:24am
Author: savedbyegrace

I feel you put things very tactfully B2Y. (Tact is unfortunately not my gift : ) I agree with you 100%. Working for the State and being surrounded predominantly by non-christians and luke warm christians, this election has really polarized the country. I am only 33 and wish I had grown up in the era so many older people were fortunate to experience. By this I only mean a simpler, kinder era. I believe that communism and socialism are more of a threat today than people realize!! As a christian you cannot help but feel singled out as 'intolerant,' if you disagree with someone's lifestyle or views on unborn life. The bible says "the man of lawlessness is already at work"... paving way for the Antichrist of course. How else will he achieve GLOBAL domination without coming as a wolf in sheeps clothing. Unifying the country, Unifying Nations, getting people excited and feeling "patriotic." We need only to remain loyal to the one who gave His life so that we might Live. If anyones views or opinions or methods don't align with the Christ, one should question it!

  Posted 01/20/2009 12:06pm
Author: forgivennotperfect

Great Blog B2Y- the crux of the matter is this- as I see it, how can a christian continue to support the country of one's birth with the loyalty that country deserves, and yes this country does deserve loyalty- and still retain one's christian principles? A tough row to hoe my friend, and yet we must hoe it. We must remind those in office that they are accountable to the people that put them in office. In this way we are 'rendering unto ceasar that which is ceasar's" And yes tolerance includes the defense of atheists, unbelievers, and those that dislike Christians on general principle. Why? because if we do not tolerate their belief systems, the fragile freedoms we currently enjoy diminish that much more rapidly. When we forget that our freedom to free speech is to be equally adminsistered is the surest way to lose that freedom.

I want to be clear- I'm not for the One World government,that will not be sucessful until Jesus Himself returns. It would be nice however to have a return to civility in the public square and respect for differing opinions and belief systems. I cannot agree to the idea that the muslim, the hindu and I believe in and worship the same God because we do not. But, respecting the right to having differing p.o.v.'s is one of the cornerstones of a democratic republic like ours.


selah

  Posted 01/20/2009 01:51pm
Author: blackrose65

Thank you for all the enlightening and civilcomments. My worry when posting an article such as this if of course that either I offend someone or it turns into a political shouting match--neither of which is wanted or allowed.

May I say again that it is not that I do not love my country, but I fail to see justification (outside of nationalist Israel in the Old Testament) for the kind of zealous patriotism that many times actually divides this country and separates it from others in the world and vice a versa. It must always be remembered that Israel in the Old Testament was a Theocracy which the United States IS NOT.

There obviously was a shift in attitude toward love of country from the Old to the New Testament. This, I believe came with the various secular empires constantly taking over the land along with the huge number of countries believers represented in the New Testament.

What I am afraid of is that the sudden surge in patriotism as manifested today in Washington will wear off in the next few months and this country will settle back into the same partisan politics which has wrecked it for years. I really do pray that those in authority forge a united and somewhat godly plan to deal with the horrible financial mess this nation is in. Isn't it odd that on this great day of joy and optimism in Washington, just up the road in New York the Stock Market lost over 300 points due to worries the banks are going broke?

Again, thank you for your great comments and I pray any further ones stay as enlightening and civil as those so far. Thank you.
B2Y

  Posted 01/20/2009 03:39pm
Author: blessings2you

You know me by now B2Y ,,,I just have to say one thing , Lord Lord help all of us to keep our hearts and eyes on you, for your coming is nigh, I do believe Jesus is coming soon, I will watch & pray for this I know is coming. Thank You AJ

  Posted 01/21/2009 01:03pm
Author: annajones

B2Y, I understand your concerns, and probably share them! However, the only people we can control directly are the ones we see in the mirror daily and this is why we are exhorted to pray for everyone in 1Tim2... . selah

  Posted 01/23/2009 12:25pm
Author: blackrose65

Very good points! This is excellent.

In college, we talked about what it meant to be political. Jesus, in fact, was a political figure. He was a political figure in in the respect that he led (and still leading) sooo many broken people, and had the bravery to stand up to the Roman government when needed. The amazing thing was, he didn't run a campaign, he had no special slogan - he simply took action. He loved. And he obeyed God.

I believe that's what we are called to do as Christians. I think too many people think being "political" or "patriotic" means to vote, to obey the government. I disagree for two reasons:
1)Our government is BASED on a system where if the 3 branches fail, the people have the right to question it. This is how it was formulated back in the day with our forefathers. This is a government by the people, and for the people.
2)Jesus did not just obey the government. Jesus was a classic "walk the walk" kind of guy. He got out there and DID something about it. When goods were being sold outside the temple, he turned the tables over. He healed people.
Most of all, he prayed. He obeyed God. He was a sinless man after all.

I feel that is our call - to simply obey God. To trust his will and his judgement. Do I agree with every policy proposed? Absolutely not. In fact, I dare say it's my "patriotic duty" AND ALSO my "Christian duty" to indeed question every law proposed and passed.
In obeying God, we also pray for those in power. God put them there, and they need God's wisdom. This next statement is in no way intended towards current leaders, but remember too, that God will eventually allow the Anti-Christ to come into a position of power. We are ALL POWERLESS to God's will - it will be done. But that's NOTHING to be cynical about. If anything, we should be praising God for His will, no matter how little sense it makes to us.
Also in obeying God, we need to search his will for our lives, too. And this means taking up our own crosses - we need to "walk the walk." We need to walk the walk in our society, in our country, in our home. Whether it be leading, helping the homeless, or just being there for someone, we are to be the salt of the earth.

One last thought - no president is perfect; no one's perfect. Even if we follow God, we will be led astray - it's just how it is. It humbles and comforts me to know that I can't put anyone on a pedestal except for God.

God bless all who read! Thanks for listening :-)
Your sister-in-Christ, Devinne

  Posted 01/26/2009 07:44pm
Author: djmeyers

In order to respond to this blog you must be a registered member and logged into the ChristianBlog.Com website.


Information:
Terms of Service
Content Policy
Privacy Policy
DMCA
Resources:
About ChristianBlog.Com
Advertising
RSS Feeds
Premier Membership
Sponsors:
LongMessage.Com
Assembly of God Jobs Online
Lamsa Bible Online
Logos Bible Software